2018 Competition Summer School for Japanese, Indian & Korean Officials

9-20 July 2018

About

T he Competition Summer School for Officials from the ASEAN Member States took place between 9th and 20th July 2018 at the College of Europe in Bruges, Belgium. The summer school was attended by 1 official from the ASEAN Secretariat, 3 officials from the Indonesian Competition Commission (KPPU), 1 official from the Malaysia Competition Commission (MyCC), 3 officials from the Philippine Competition Commission (PCC), 3 officials from the Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore (CCCS), 1 official from the Office of Trade Competition Commission Thailand and 2 officials from the Vietnam Competition Authority.

At the College of Europe campus, the officials followed an intensive 10-day training course designed to deepen their knowledge and understanding of EU competition law and policy. Leading academics and practitioners introduced a wide range of topics, including the institutional framework, economic analysis, horizontal and vertical restraints, abusive conduct and merger control. Focussing specifically on competition policy and its challenges in the context of ASEAN, the programme focused also on economic and non-economic goals of competition law, decentralised application and enforcement of EU competition law and the coexistence of EU and national regimes. The lectures combined theory with practical experience in the form of recent cases and examples, which encouraged class discussions on approaches and experiences within their jurisdictions.

On 10 July, the officials joined their counterparts from China, India, Japan and Korea for a day visit to the European Directorate-General for Competition in Brussels. Officials from DG Competition and the General Court of the European Union introduced the officials to DG Competition, the European Competition Network, the Court of Justice of the EU and EU policy on merger review, state aid and antitrust and cartel enforcement. The closing remarks were delivered by Mr. Johannes Laitenberger, Director-General at DG Competition.

All 14 officials successfully completed the Competition Summer School and received their certificates during the official closing ceremony on 20 July.

Schedule

Bruges, Belgium

09:00-09:30: Welcome to the College of Europe & Presentation of the Programme

09:30-10:45: Institutions and decision-making in the EU (I)

Mihail KRITIKOS

10:45-11:00: Tea break

11:00-12:00: Institutions and decision-making in the EU (II)

Mihail KRITIKOS

12:00-14:00: Lunch

14:00-15:30: Objectives of EU competition law

Focus on market integration, fairness and innovation, in addition to more traditional economic goals

Michael ALBERS

15:30-15:45: Tea break

15:45-17:00: Instruments of EU competition law

Michael ALBERS

19:00: Dinner

Brussels, Belgium

07:00: Transfer by bus to Brussels

09:30-09:40: Welcome to DG Competition

Kris DEKEYSER

09:40-10:00: Overview of DG Competition

Torben TOFT

10:00-10:45: European Competition Network

Konstantina STROUVALI

11:00-11:45: EU Merger review

Stefan SIMON

12:00-14:00: Lunch

13:30-14:45: EU state aid policy

Koen VAN DE CASTEELE

15:00-15:45: EU antitrust/cartel enforcement

Konrad SCHUMM

16:00-17:00: Court of Justice of the European Union

Savvas S. PAPASAVVAS

17:15-17:30: Closing session

Johannes LAITENBERGER

Bruges, Belgium

09:00-11:00: Competition policy and fundamentals of EU competition law (I)

Michael ALBERS

11:00-11:15: Tea break

11:15-12:30: Competition policy and fundamentals of EU competition law (II)

Michael ALBERS

12:30-14:30: Lunch

14:30-15:45: Competition policy and fundamentals of EU competition law (III)

Case study

Michael ALBERS

15:45-16:00: Tea break

16:00-17:30: Competition policy and fundamentals of EU competition law (IV)

Case study

Michael ALBERS

19:00: Dinner

Bruges, Belgium

09:00-11:00: Economcis of competition law (I)

x
Andrea RENDA

11:00-11:15: Tea break

11:15-12:30: Economics of competition law (II)

Andrea RENDA

12:30-14:30: Lunch

14:30-15:45: Economics of competition law (III)

Andrea RENDA

15:45-16:00: Tea break

16:00-17:30: Economics of competition law (IV)

Andrea RENDA

19:00: Dinner

Bruges, Belgium

09:00-11:00: Article 101 – Horizontal restraints (fundamentals) (I)

Cartels, concerted practices, damage calculation, legal exception and exemptions

Jacques BOURGEOIS

11:00-11:15: Tea break

11:15-12:30: Article 101 – Horizontal restraints (fundamentals) (II)

Cartels, concerted practices, damage calculation, legal exception and exemptions

Jacques BOURGEOIS

12:30-14:30: Lunch

14:30-15:45: Article 101 – Horizontal restraints (landmark cases) (III)

Cartels: object restrictions Pay-for-delay agreements in the pharmaceutical industry

Jacques BOURGEOIS

15:45-16:00: Tea break

16:00-17:30: Article 101 – Horizontal restraints (landmark cases) (IV)

Non-cartel cases

Jacques BOURGEOIS

19:00: Dinner

Bruges, Belgium

09:00-11:00: State aid control (fundamentals) (I)

Phedon NICOLAIDES

11:00-11:15: Tea break

11:15-12:30: State aid control (fundamentals) (II)

Phedon NICOLAIDES

12:30-14:30: Lunch

14:30-15:45: State aid control (case study) (III)

Phedon NICOLAIDES

15:45-16:00: Tea break

16:00-17:30: State aid control (case study and discussion) (IV)

Tax rulings

Phedon NICOLAIDES

19:00: Dinner

Bruges, Belgium

09:00-11:00: Anti-trust procedure – Regulation 1/2003 (fundamentals) (I)

Public v private enforcement; decentralised enforcement; coordination between the Commission and NCAs

Alfonso LAMADRID

11:00-11:15: Tea break

11:15-12:30: Anti-trust procedure – Regulation 1/2003 (case study) (II)

Alfonso LAMADRID

12:30-14:30: Lunch

14:30-15:45: Article 106 – Public and privileged undertakings (fundamentals) (I)

Alfonso LAMADRID

15:45-16:00: Tea break

16:00-17:30: Article 106 – Public and privileged undertakings (II)

Practical examples

Alfonso LAMADRID

19:00: Dinner

Bruges, Belgium

09:00-10:45: Mergers and acquisitions (fundamentals) (I)

Basic concepts and regulations, procedures for remedy, rules for merger investigation procedures, advantages of compulsory notification

Anna DURON

11:00-11:15: Tea break

11:00-12:30: Mergers and acquisitions (specific issues) (II)

Tailored to preferences of participants

Anna DURON

12:30-14:30: Lunch

14:30-15:45: Mergers and acquisitions (procedure and remedies) (III)

Economic analysis in merger investigations, fix-it-first remedy and up-front buyer, EU communication and cooperation with enforcement bureaus in other jurisdictions when investigating the same merger cases, extraterritoriality

Anna DURON

15:45-16:00: Tea break

16:00-17:30: Mergers and acquisitions (case study) (IV)

Practical examples. Gencor, GE/Honwewell, Boeing

Anna DURON

19:00: Dinner

Bruges, Belgium

09:00-10:45: Article 102 – Abuse of dominant position (fundamentals) (I)

Investigation and enforcement of abuse of dominance cases

Bill BATCHELOR

11:00-11:15: Tea break

11:00-12:30: Article 102 – Abuse of dominant position (fundamentals) (II)

Basic principles of 102 TFEU

Bill BATCHELOR

12:30-14:30: Lunch

14:30-15:45: Article 102 – Abuse of dominant position (landmark cases) (I)

Pricing abuses

Bill BATCHELOR

15:45-16:00: Tea break

16:00-17:30: Article 102 – Abuse of dominant position (landmark cases) (II)

Non-pricing abuses

Bill BATCHELOR

19:00: Dinner

Bruges, Belgium

08:30-10:45: Article 101 – Vertical restraints (fundamentals) (I)

Andrea HAMILON

11:00-11:15: Tea break

11:00-12:30: Article 101 – Vertical restraints (case study) (II)

Consten & Grundig, STM, Pronuptia

Andrea HAMILTON

12:30-14:30: Lunch

14:30-15:45: International issues and the globalisation of competition law (I)

Hector ARMENGOD

15:45-16:00: Tea break

16:00-17:00: International issues and the globalisation of competition law (II)

EU’s competition law system including rules, regulations and guidelines with regard to the dominance position, theories on identifying relevant markets

Hector ARMENGOD

17:00-17:30: Official Closure & Awarding of Certificates

19:00: Dinner